Why I'd Tell Clients NOT To Buy

Somewhere along the way, buying a house stopped being a decision and became a milestone you're apparently behind on. Your college roommate just closed on a place. Your parents keep asking when you're going to "stop throwing money away on rent." Your algorithm is an endless abyss of fancy countertops and furniture dupes and sold signs. And there you are, pre-approved and terrified, wondering if the problem is you.

So let me say the thing nobody at the open house is going to say: sometimes the smartest move you can make is to not make one.

I've talked people out of houses they loved. Not because the house was ugly, not because I didn't want the sale, but because I could see the thing they couldn't. And ten years into this, I've learned that the "no" I give in month one is the reason they're still my client in year ten.

Here's what I'm usually seeing when I say wait.

Sometimes you're buying for a reason that has nothing to do with a house. A breakup you're trying to outrun. A job you started ninety days ago that makes great money, but you're not totally sure will stick. A version of "settled" you think a mortgage will hand you. But a house doesn't fix a wobbly year. It just adds hundreds of thousands dollars of commitment to it. If your life is mid-plot-twist, that's not the moment to sign a thirty-year contract with a zip code.

Sometimes it's the math, and the math is quietly screaming. You can technically qualify, but qualifying and being able to afford it are two different sentences. If the down payment empties your savings to zero, if there's no cushion for the water heater that will absolutely die in year one, if the monthly payment only works in a spreadsheet where nothing ever goes wrong, then the house isn't an asset yet. It's a hostage situation with good natural light.

And sometimes, honestly, you don't even want to own. You want the idea of owning. You want the version of you who has a mudroom and hosts things. But you also want to be able to move next year, or take the job in another city, or not be the person who has to reseal the deck. There is nothing wrong with renting on purpose. Renting isn't the waiting room for a real life. For a lot of people, at a lot of moments, it's the smarter financial call, and I'll be the one to tell you so.

The hard part is that none of this is what you want to hear when you've already picked out where the couch goes.

I get it. I've moved more times than I can count, most of it before I was old enough to have a say in it, and I know exactly how much a person can crave the feeling of finally, somewhere that's mine. That longing is real and it deserves respect. It just doesn't deserve to be the thing making a six-figure decision for you.

So when I tell you to wait, it isn't me being cautious with your money like it's mine. It's me refusing to let you buy your way into a problem you'll be untangling for years. The right house at the wrong time is still the wrong house.

So then I couldn't help but wonder: maybe the real flex isn't buying the moment you're able to? Maybe it's being honest enough with yourself to know when "able to" and "ready to" aren't the same thing yet, and having someone in your corner who'll say it out loud.

That someone is happy to be me.


Thinking about buying and quietly hoping someone will tell you the truth about your timing? That's the whole job. Let's talk it through before you fall for a house that isn't right for this chapter of your life.

Reach out: [email protected]

Because the best real estate decision you make this year might be the one you don't.

P.S. — If I ever tell you not to buy, it's not me losing a sale. It's me betting on working with you for the next decade instead of the next thirty days.

Check out this article next

The Question Nobody Asks at a Showing

The Question Nobody Asks at a Showing

I have been to a lot of showings. Years of them. And I have noticed a pattern in what buyers ask and what they do…

Read Article
About the Author